(September 2011) U.S. 2010 Census results show that black-white residential segregation declined modestly since 2000, continuing the gradual pace begun in 1980.
Among large metropolitan areas with a total population of 500,000 or more, the least segregated metros were located in the faster-growing South and West, while the most segregated metro areas were mainly concentrated in the slower-growing Northeast and Midwest (see table).
The 10 least-segregated metro areas all grew faster than the national average of 11 percent between 2000 and 2010, with seven of them seeing increases of 20 percent or more, reports Kelvin Pollard, PRB demographer and co-author of PRB’s Reports on America: “First Results From the 2010 Census.” Only one of the 10 most-segregated metros experienced growth rates that reached even half the national average.
“Least-segregated Raleigh and Las Vegas were among the nation’s fastest growing metros with growth rates topping more than 40 percent for the decade, while most-segregated Detroit, Cleveland, and Buffalo were among those that lost population,” he notes.
Demographers use the segregation (or dissimilarity) index to measure how racial groups are spread throughout a metro area’s census tracts. An index of 100 would mean blacks live in exclusively black neighborhoods and whites live in exclusively white neighborhoods, while a score of zero means each neighborhood has the same share of black and white residents as the metro area as a whole.
“Milwaukee’s index of 81.5 means that about eight out of 10 black residents would need to move to another Milwaukee neighborhood to be distributed throughout the metro area in the same way as whites,” Pollard explains. Demographers call levels of 60 and above highly segregated, 39 to 59 moderately segregated, and below 39 less segregated.
Ten Least and Most Segregated Metropolitan Areas With Population Change, 2000 to 2010
|Least Black-White Segregated Metros||Segregation Index, 2010||Percent Population Change, 2000-2010|
|Las Vegas-Paradise, Nev.||37.6||41.8|
|Colorado Springs, Colo.||39.3||20.1|
|Charleston-North Charleston-Summerville, S.C.||41.5||21.1|
|Lakeland-Winter Haven, Fla.||43.9||24.4|
|Augusta-Richmond County, Ga.-S.C.||45.2||11.5|
|Riverside-San Bernardino-Ontario, Calif.||45.7||29.8|
|Most Black-White Segregated Metros||Segregation Index, 2010||Percent Population Change,
|Milwaukee-Waukesha-West Allis, Wisc.||81.5||3.7|
|New York-Northern New Jersey-Long Island, N.Y.-N.J.-Pa.||78.0||3.1|
|Buffalo-Niagara Falls, N.Y.||73.2||-3.0|
|St. Louis, Mo.-Ill.||72.3||4.3|
|Los Angeles-Long Beach-Santa Ana, Calif.||67.8||3.7|
Note: Metro areas with fewer than 500,000 total residents or where non-Hispanic blacks made up fewer than 3 percent of the population were not included when ranking black-white segregation indices.
Sources: Segregation Indices: William H. Frey, Brookings Institution, and University of Michigan Social Science Data Analysis Network, Analysis of 1990, 2000, and 2010 Decennial Census tract data, accessed at www.psc.isr.umich.edu/dis/census/segregation2010.html, on Aug. 29, 2011. Population Data: Population Reference Bureau, analysis of 2000 and 2010 Decennial Census data.
Rustbelt Ghettoes Not Replicated Elsewhere
Segregation persists in older cities in the Northeast and Midwest where a large share of the nation’s African American residents live, “buttressed by a history of poor race relations and continuing discrimination,” says John Iceland, a Penn State University demographer who studies segregation and poverty. Cities like Chicago, Detroit, and Philadelphia have long-established black communities—often called ghettos—that grew during the migration of African Americans from the South for industrial jobs during the first half of the 1900s.
Still, the 2010 Census results offer some good news: “The ghettoes of the Northeast and Midwest are not being reconstituted in the fast-growing areas of the South and West,” he notes.
U.S. cities with high levels of growth and new construction tend to be less segregated. One reason may be that newer housing lacks a reputation for discrimination, while in older areas the perception—widely held or not—that blacks are unwelcome in a particular suburb or area of the city can linger for decades. Metro areas in the South and West tend to have more mobile populations, fewer blacks, and sometimes no long-established black community, Iceland points out. “The world of difference is easy to see in a short drive through Milwaukee or Detroit where there are starkly black and starkly white neighborhoods that you don’t see to nearly the same extent driving in places like Tucson or Las Vegas,” he says.
The way city boundaries were drawn in the past also plays a role in regional differences today, according to Reynolds Farley, a University of Michigan sociology professor emeritus, who began studying segregation in the 1960s. The boundaries of the Rustbelt cities of the Northeast and Midwest were established decades ago and are surrounded by independent suburbs, some with a history of hostility to blacks. In the South and West, central cities annexed outlying land after World War II; metro areas like Tucson include much of what might be considered the suburban ring in the Midwest. In some parts of the West and South, public schools are often organized on a county-wide basis, limiting white suburban enclaves.
By the 1990s, more African Americans were calling the suburbs home, but in many places those suburbs were predominantly black. “The important finding revealed by Census 2010 is that many, many places within suburban rings in the Northeast and Midwest appear to be quite open to African American residents,” says Farley. “You can find almost all-black neighborhoods, but such segregation is certainly declining. In quite a few metro areas in the South and West and some in the Midwest, you could say that black-white segregation is not much more than moderate.”
Researchers are now tracking the impact of growing Hispanic and Asian populations on black-white segregation. “As a community becomes more diverse, racial mixing appears easier to achieve and a different dynamic seems to be playing out,” says Iceland.
Gradual, Steady, but Limited Progress
Black-white segregation has declined gradually and continuously over the last 40 years, but as the nation’s population has become more diverse some analysts anticipated more rapid change, even hoping for a breakthrough.
“The growth of the black middle class, the passage of time since Fair Housing Laws were enacted, and the evidence from surveys that white Americans are becoming more tolerant of black neighbors all point toward progress in overcoming the high level of segregation that had been reached in 1970,” says Brown University sociology professor John Logan.
A report from the US2010 Census Project, directed by Logan, found overall black-white residential segregation in U.S. metropolitan areas declined from a high of 79 in 1970 to 59 in 2010 (as measured by the segregation index).1 Logan calls the progress “mixed,” noting that at the current rate of change it will be 2030 before blacks reach the same level of segregation as Hispanics today (index of 48). The report also found that cities with the largest share of black residents registered the smallest declines in segregation over the past 30 years, while metro areas with black populations of less than 5 percent showed the greatest declines.
One cost of residential segregation for African Americans is quality of life. The neighborhoods where they live typically have fewer resources and higher poverty than neighborhoods where comparable non-Hispanic whites live, according to the US2010 Census Project.2 The average black household earning more than $75,000 was in a neighborhood with a higher poverty rate than the average white household earning less than $40,000.
Children More Segregated Than Adults
For children, segregation continues to be more pronounced than for adults. The Harvard School of Public Health’s Diversity Data project reports that segregation declined moderately for black children in most U.S. metropolitan areas since 2000, but remains high.3 Their analysis of 2010 Census data found that black child segregation relative to white children in the 100 largest metropolitan areas fell between 2000 and 2010 from 72 to 68, as measured by the segregation index. Child segregation declined most in larger, very highly segregated metros in the Midwest and smaller metros in Florida and the western United States, the researchers found.
“In very few instances do the very best neighborhoods where black and Hispanic children live have opportunities and amenities close to the average level of neighborhoods where white children live,” write the Diversity Data project authors.
Farley calls “residential segregation a lens to assess whether the U.S. has achieved the equality that some felt the 2008 election symbolized.”4 He points to declines in segregation, increases in interracial marriages, documented changes in racial attitudes, and widespread acceptance of equal housing opportunities as signs of weakened systemic discrimination.
Yet he acknowledges that while white attitudes have become more accepting over the past 30 years, full acceptance is a long way off. About half of whites surveyed in Detroit in 2004 told Farley’s research team they would move if the racial composition of their neighborhoods reaches 50-50, down from three-quarters in 1976. Still, he is cautiously optimistic: “The long trend toward lower levels of black-white segregation seems sure to continue.”
Paola Scommegna is a senior writer/editor at the Population Reference Bureau.
- John R. Logan and Brian Stults, “The Persistence of Segregation in the Metropolis: New Findings from the 2010 Census,” Project US2010 Census Brief (March 2011), accessed at www.s4.brown.edu/us2010, on Aug. 20, 2011.
- John Logan, “Separate and Unequal: The Neighborhood Gap for Blacks, Hispanics, and Asians in Metropolitan America,” Project US2010 Report (July 2011), accessed at www.s4.brown.edu/us2010/Data/Report/report0727.pdf, on Aug. 30, 2011.
- Nancy McArdle et al., “Segregation Falls for Black Children in Most Metro Area but Remains High; Fewer Metros Experience Declines for Latinos,” Diversity Data Issue Brief (July 2011), accessed at http://diversitydata.sph.harvard.edu/Publications/Child_Segregation_Issue_Brief_July_2011.pdf, on Aug. 1, 2011.
- Reynolds Farley, “The Waning of American Apartheid?” Contexts 10, no. 3 (2011), accessed at www.psc.isr.umich.edu/pubs/pdf/rp617.pdf, on Aug. 30, 2011.